The Darnold Dilemma: Assessing the 49ers’ Quarterback Shuffle

Sam Darnold named 49ers No. 2 QB; Trey Lance absent from practice, per reports

By Bryan DeArdo

August 23, 2023

Lance’s future with the team is in doubt

It’s been a rollercoaster ride for Trey Lance, the highly anticipated quarterback for the San Francisco 49ers. Just a year ago, he was on the verge of becoming the team’s starting quarterback, but now his future with the team is uncertain. Reports indicate that the 49ers have named Sam Darnold as the team’s No. 2 quarterback, leaving Lance on the sidelines.

A questionable decision

The decision to elevate Darnold while potentially shopping Lance raises eyebrows. Lance has shown promise in the preseason, displaying better numbers than Darnold. He threw for more yards and had a higher passer rating. However, the team may be making a pragmatic business decision. With Darnold proving himself as a capable backup, the 49ers could potentially trade Lance for more value, considering his young age and potential.

A turbulent journey for Lance

Trey Lance’s journey with the 49ers has been filled with ups and downs. He started only four games in his first two years with mixed results, completing just 55% of his passes with five touchdowns and three interceptions. Last season, he had the opportunity to start when Jimmy Garoppolo got injured, but his season was cut short due to an injury. Despite his limited playing time, several teams may be interested in acquiring Lance as a quality backup.

The value of a quality backup

Many teams in the NFL understand the importance of having a capable backup quarterback. This demand increases the likelihood of significant interest in a possible trade for Lance. The 49ers must carefully consider their asking price for Lance, as it will ultimately determine whether he is traded quickly or at all.

The rise of Sam Darnold

While Trey Lance’s future is uncertain, the 49ers‘ decision to elevate Sam Darnold to the No. 2 quarterback spot speaks to Darnold’s capabilities. Darnold, the third overall pick in the 2018 NFL Draft, has had a turbulent career, starting on subpar teams with the New York Jets before spending the past two seasons as a spot-starter in Carolina. However, he showed promise last season, going 4-2 as the Panthers’ starting quarterback while throwing more touchdown passes than interceptions.

Editorial: The importance of a quarterback shuffle assessment

This situation with the 49ers highlights the importance of thorough quarterback assessments. The decision to elevate Darnold over Lance implies that the team has analyzed various factors, from on-field performance to potential trade value. This careful evaluation is crucial for any team looking to build a formidable roster. It ensures that the right players are in the right positions, maximizing the team’s chances of success.

Advice: Navigating a complex quarterback situation

For the 49ers and other teams facing similar quarterback dilemmas, it is essential to strike a balance between short-term success and long-term planning. The immediate success of a quality backup like Darnold can provide stability, but it is equally important to consider the potential of a young talent like Lance. Teams should carefully assess their roster, their needs, and the offers they receive in trade discussions before making a final decision. Ultimately, making the right evaluation will determine the team’s direction and chances of achieving their goals.