Opinion | The Brawl in Montgomery: A Catalyst for Clarity

A Brawl That Was, for Some, a Clarifying Moment

Opinion by Charles M. Blow

The recent brawl that took place on the riverfront dock in Montgomery, Alabama, has sparked a broader conversation about the experiences of Black people in America and their responses to ongoing racial violence. While the incident itself is sad and should never have escalated into violence, it is important to recognize the underlying historical context and the deep-rooted trauma faced by the Black community. This incident has become a clarifying moment for many, shedding light on the complex dynamics of self-defense and the urgent need for collective action against racial injustice.

Understanding the Historical Context

The history of violence against Black people in America stretches back centuries, beginning with the brutalization of Black bodies under slavery. Whippings, rapes, hangings, and other forms of violence were inflicted upon Black individuals, often without anyone coming to their defense. This brutal treatment became a central theme in Black literature, exemplified by Toni Morrison’s novel “Beloved,” where the protagonist’s husband witnesses her violent assault but is powerless to intervene. Lynchings and racial violence persisted in the decades following slavery, with instances of resistance overwhelmed by a larger narrative of victimization.

The Civil Rights Movement and the Power of Imagery

The civil rights movement brought a renewed focus on nonviolent resistance, exposing the cruel and depraved nature of Southern racists. Yet, despite the success of this tactic, it also resulted in powerful imagery of Black victimization. Rodney King’s beating in Los Angeles, Eric Garner’s choking in New York, and George Floyd’s murder in Minneapolis, all captured on camera, have become symbols of the ongoing struggle against racism. The vicarious trauma experienced by Black individuals who witness these incidents is amplified by the realization that they, too, could be victims and that there is no guarantee of rescue or justice.

The Montgomery Brawl as a Departure from the Norm

Against this backdrop, the brawl in Montgomery stands out as a departure from the norm. It provided an outlet for the righteous indignation of the Black community, as individuals came to the defense of a Black man under attack. For many, witnessing this act of solidarity offered a sense of historical correction and therapy. The location of the brawl in Alabama further adds poetic resonance, as it is a state with a dark history of slavery and racialized violence.

The Morality of Self-Defense

While violence is never ideal, it is crucial to understand the morality of self-defense. Black individuals should not be expected to endure violence without defending themselves or being defended by others. The Montgomery police chief acknowledged that members of the riverboat’s crew came to the defense of Damien Pickett, recognizing their right to protect themselves and their community. It is important to hope for peaceful resolutions and cooler heads, but it is equally important to acknowledge that there are times when defense becomes necessary and standing upright becomes the only appropriate response to injustice.

Conclusion

The brawl in Montgomery has exposed the deep-seated trauma and ongoing racial violence faced by Black individuals in America. It serves as a clarifying moment, reminding us of the urgent need for collective action against racism and the importance of self-defense when confronted with violence. While it is essential to strive for peaceful resolutions in all situations, it is equally important to recognize that no one should be obligated to endure violence without defending themselves. Moving forward, we must continue the dialogue on racial justice and work towards a society that upholds the dignity and safety of all its citizens.