The Symbolic Struggle: Voices from Sonoma County on the Meaning of Our Flag

‘Our Flag Wars’: Sonoma County Residents Weigh in on the Meaning of the American Flag as Nation Celebrates Independence

The Complexity of Symbolism

The American flag has always carried a multitude of meanings for different Americans. To some, it represents democracy and freedom, while to others, it symbolizes military might and oppression. In the current moment, however, the flag has taken on an even more complicated set of meanings. The recent events at the U.S. Capitol on January 6, 2021, where the flag was present during the riot, exemplify the confusion surrounding its symbolism. With this backdrop, The Press Democrat spoke to a handful of Sonoma County residents to gauge their perceptions of the American flag in 2023.

Freedom of Speech and Democracy

For Greg Fairbrother, a former social studies teacher who lived in Hong Kong, the American flag represents freedom of speech. Fairbrother experienced the erosion of civil liberties in Hong Kong and witnessed youth-led protests where many waved American flags to symbolize the democratic ideals they aspired to. Now back in the United States, Fairbrother values the freedom to openly express his views without fear of censorship or persecution. Fairbrother and his husband proudly display the American flag alongside other flags that represent their identities, such as the colonial flag of Hong Kong and the Pride flag, as symbols of the diverse freedoms they enjoy in their home country.

A Symbol of Service and Sacrifice

For Dave Phillips, who served in the military for 22 years, including in Vietnam, the American flag holds a deep personal significance. Phillips sees the flag as a symbol of service and sacrifice, reminding him of his own dedication to protecting the freedoms that others enjoy. Phillips feels immense pride when he sees the flag and is troubled by any mockery directed towards it.

Conflicted Emotions

For MaDonna Feather Cruz, an advocate for tribal causes and an enrolled member of the Round Valley Indian Tribes, the American flag evokes conflicting emotions. Feather Cruz’s grandfather served in the U.S. Army during World War II, and she feels pride in his service. However, she also acknowledges the historical injustices committed against Native American communities by the U.S. government. Feather Cruz suggests that while she respects the American flag, she does not personally feel represented by it.

Opportunity and Disillusionment

Andre Achacon, a recent graduate of Santa Rosa High School whose parents moved to the United States from the Philippines, sees the American flag as a symbol of opportunity. Achacon values the access to education and public services that his parents sought for his future. However, Achacon acknowledges that many young people, like himself, have grown disillusioned with what the flag represents due to recent court decisions and political rhetoric. Despite his reservations, Achacon remains enthusiastic about his country and aspires to participate in effecting positive change.

Bridging Divisions and Encouraging Dialogue

Tennis Wick, the director of Permit Sonoma, emphasizes the importance of the American flag in daily operations. Wick believes that the presence of the flag symbolizes cooperation and unity within the local government and between the federal government and its subdivisions. Wick flies the American flag at his home and views it as an instrument that stimulates conversations, both uplifting and uncomfortable, which he feels can ultimately foster connections among Americans.

The Historical Context

Steve Estes, a history professor at Sonoma State University, contextualizes America’s complex relationship with its flag throughout the past century. From World War II, where the flag united Americans during a time of fear, to the Civil Rights era, when Black Americans used it to assert their right to equal protection under the law, to the Vietnam era, when it became a symbol for peace protests and counterculture movements. Estes highlights that symbols, like the flag, can represent various meanings based on individual perspectives.

Embracing American Symbols

Estes believes that liberals should not shy away from embracing symbols of American identity, such as the eagle or the American flag. He suggests that doing so would allow liberals to show their pro-American stance and bridge the gap of understanding between different ideological groups in the country.

The Good, the Bad, and the Indifferent

Estes acknowledges that attaching the American flag to certain causes or vehicles may raise eyebrows. Yet, he stresses his pride in being an American and the gratitude he has for the country despite its imperfections. The flag, according to Estes, serves as a reminder of both the achievements and the challenges faced by the nation.

Editorial: Embracing a Multifaceted Symbol

The discussions with Sonoma County residents demonstrate the rich and diverse meanings that the American flag holds for individuals. It reflects the values of freedom, democracy, service, opportunity, and the need for introspection and progress. Rather than allowing the flag to become a source of division, it is important to embrace its multifaceted symbolism.

While some may attempt to hijack the flag for their political agenda, it is imperative to remember that the flag belongs to all Americans. Each person’s interpretation of the flag is influenced by their own experiences, beliefs, and values. The beauty of a diverse society lies in the ability to engage in conversation and listen to the perspectives of others.

It is essential to recognize that the American flag is not a stagnant symbol. It has evolved over time and will continue to do so as society progresses. Embracing symbols of American identity, regardless of political affiliation, can foster a sense of unity and shared purpose.

Advice: Fostering Understanding and Dialogue

In a time of deep divisions, it is crucial to find common ground and build bridges of understanding. Here are a few recommendations to encourage respectful dialogue and the promotion of unity:

1. Engage in Conversation:

Take the time to listen to different perspectives and engage in conversations about what the American flag represents. Approach discussions with an open mind and a willingness to learn from others.

2. Educate Yourself:

Learn about the historical context of the American flag and its various interpretations throughout history. Understanding its complexity can help foster empathy and respect for differing viewpoints.

3. Embrace Shared Values:

Focus on the shared values that the American flag represents, such as freedom, equality, and the pursuit of a better future. Recognize that these values are not exclusive to any particular political ideology.

4. Celebrate Diversity:

Acknowledge and appreciate the diverse range of identities and perspectives that exist within the United States. By celebrating diversity, we can create an inclusive society that respects the rights and experiences of all individuals.

5. Encourage Civic Engagement:

Inspire young people to actively participate in civic life and work towards positive change. Encourage them to pursue careers in public service and support organizations that promote democratic ideals and values.

By fostering understanding, embracing diversity, and engaging in respectful dialogue, we can ensure that the American flag continues to represent the spirit of unity, freedom, and progress for all Americans.