The casting of Adele James, a mixed-heritage Black actress, as Cleopatra in the Netflix original series “African Queens” has triggered a backlash in Egypt, where some claim that the queen was of European descent and not Black. As a result, Egypt’s state-owned Al Wathaeqya channel has announced production of a high-budget documentary on the “true” story of Cleopatra, which it claims will be historically accurate.
However, the controversy raises important questions about the nature of historical accuracy and cultural representation in film and television.
Historical Accuracy and Cultural Representation
The controversy over “African Queens” raises questions about the nature of historical accuracy and cultural representation in film and television. On one hand, filmmakers and producers have a duty to ensure that their works adhere to the facts and do not perpetuate harmful stereotypes. On the other hand, they also have a responsibility to challenge and subvert dominant narratives in order to provide audiences with a more diverse and nuanced understanding of history and society.
In the case of Cleopatra, the historical record is contested, with some scholars claiming that she was of Greek or Macedonian descent, while others argue that she had African or Egyptian roots. While it may be impossible to know for sure what Cleopatra looked like, it is important to recognize that the representation of historical figures on screen is never purely objective or neutral, and that these representations are always shaped by cultural and political forces.
Cultural appropriation or Cultural appreciation?
The controversy over “African Queens” also highlights the tensions surrounding cultural appropriation and cultural appreciation. While some in Egypt have accused Netflix of trying to “take over our Egyptian culture,” others have argued that the casting of a Black actress as Cleopatra is a powerful example of cultural appreciation, and an opportunity to challenge and subvert dominant narratives about race and identity.
Ultimately, the controversy over “African Queens” raises important questions about the relationship between film and history, and the role of film and television in shaping our understanding of the past and the present. While historical accuracy and cultural representation are important, it is also essential to recognize the complex and contested nature of history, and to be open to new and diverse perspectives. In the end, it is only through open and honest dialogue that we can hope to create a more inclusive and equitable world.
<< photo by Yousef Rageb >>
